With the statute authorizing state standardized tests due to expire in June 2014, the incoming Legislature is facing some difficult decisions on the future of the state testing system: What subjects should be tested, for whom, how oftentimes (not every year in every field of study, mayhap), at what toll, and, perhaps the biggest question, for what purpose?

The state volition likely end upward with a hybrid system, a combination of country-created tests and tests designed in partnerships with other states. The principal partnership is Smarter Balanced Cess Consortium, one of 2 multistate consortia with contracts with the U.South. Section of Pedagogy to develop an assessment organization aligned to theCommon Core State Standards. Smarter Counterbalanced is designing tests for California and two dozen other states. Its new tests are expected to be more demanding and will require new approaches to teaching. Simply the tests, due to curl out in spring 2015, will  encompass but math and English language language arts in grades three through eight and an important 11th form higher and career readiness assessment.

That leaves other grades, starting with 2nd course, which California currently tests, as well as science, social studies, end-of-course high schoolhouse exams and CAHSEE, the loftier school go out exam, forth with the redesign of tests for English learners and special didactics students.

Legislators must decide which tests should be administered with incomplete information; Smarter Counterbalanced officials accept acknowledged that the more intricate Common Core assessments, which promise to measure disquisitional thinking and higher-lodge skills, will have longer and toll more than the current multiple-pick California Standards Tests, which average viii-nine hours per course (less in elementary, more in high school) and $13 per student. Initial estimates are at least 50 percent more in time and expense for the math and English language arts tests, which will include short and long-response questions requiring that students show and explain the reasons behind their answers.

Over the by year, an advisory commission to State Superintendent of Public Pedagogy Tom Torlakson has hashed through the issues during 8 solar day-long meetings. Incorporating the committee'southward thoughts  and more than ane,000 public comments that he received, Torlakson will effect a report with his perspective quondam in the adjacent few weeks. Simply that study is more probable to be outline options than make definitive recommendations, said Torlakson spokesperson Paul Hefner.

The challenge will be to make audio decisions when so much is in flux.

  • California is 1 of ii dozen states taking a pb role in writing the Next Generation Scientific discipline Standards, based on a framework created by the National Research Council, affiliated with the National Academy of Sciences. Like the Common Core standards, new scientific discipline standards will stress conceptual noesis and principles over rote noesis. The final standards are due to be released by the end of this year. In one case they're complete, California must decide whether to create its ain tests or develop them with other states.
  • Before this calendar month, the State Board adopted new English Language Development standards for English learners that are aligned to Common Core country standards in reading and writing. New assessments must now be created.
  • In funding Smarter Counterbalanced and PARCC, the other consortium with 23 member states, to create Common Cadre assessments, Congress required that the tests encounter electric current federal accountability requirements. But Congress has remained deadlocked on reauthorizing the No Child Left Behind law, so it'south unclear how much the requirements might alter.
  • Smarter Counterbalanced has committed to creating tests that will use online technologies. They non but will be administered on computers, only they'll also be computer-adaptive – individually tailored, assigning questions based on students' answers to previous questions. Estimator-adaptive tests can reveal how many grades alee or backside students are; thus, in theory, the 11th grade Smarter Balanced test could replace the country's high school exit exam. But computer-adaptive tests also require a much larger library of questions than regular standardized tests, likewise as sophisticated software. Skeptics question whether the consortium will fulfill its demanding commitments; even if they exercise, information technology'south an open up question whether many California districts volition have the broadband capacity and the needed computers  by 2022 to administer the test. For those that don't, Smarter Counterbalanced has promised pen-and-newspaper tests for iii years as a fallback.

"We're non sure what calculator-adaptive can practise," said Country Lath of Education President Michael Kirst, a member of Torlakson's Advisory Committee. "Tin information technology actually (supersede) the exit exam? There are a lot of unknowns: what we tin afford, how long Smarter Balanced will accept, whether we will have to go to pencil and paper to simulate a computer."

  • At to the lowest degree in California, the pendulum is swinging in the opposition management; after a decade of testing nether No Kid Left Behind and 15 years under California'south STAR (Standardized Testing and Reporting) system, state policymakers are ready to deemphasize the office of standardized tests in the school accountability system, the API (Bookish Performance Alphabetize). Last year, the Legislature passed and Gov. Jerry Brown signed SB 1458, which will require the utilise of criteria other than examination results for 40 per centum of a high schoolhouse'southward API score. Torlakson and the Country Board will decide what those measurements will be, with an emphasis on career and higher readiness criteria, such as Advanced Placement participation, availability of career and technical education and a school's dropout rate. Because country and federal accountability systems accept been skewed so heavily toward math and English language linguistic communication arts tests, to the detriment of other subjects, Torlakson will recommend to the Legislature giving more than weight to exams in history and the sciences.

Combine all of the uncertainties and cantankerous-currents of opinions, and the Legislature volition be left with a series of tough questions:

  • What are the tradeoffs, in price and length of tests, as the country takes the lead from Smarter Counterbalanced and, in state-administered tests, shifts from pure multiple-option tests toward more circuitous assessments using short answers and lengthy problem-solving tasks?
  • Tin can the country afford the money, and schools afford the time, to administer more complex tests in every discipline every yr?
  • Assuming the country won't have all new land tests in place by the spring of 2022 – all but a certainty – what should the phase-in menstruation be?
  • Can the Smarter Balanced assessments incorporate the states' current high school exit exam?
  • Should the examination for second form exist a purely diagnostic test, to inform parents and teachers, and not be included in the country's schoolhouse accountability system?
  • Should terminate-of-course exams in loftier school, ranging from Biology and Physics to Algebra II and Summative Math,  be turned over to districts to be administered locally and excluded from the state accountability arrangement?
  • Will the state, in club to salvage coin and time on some tests, use matrix sampling, in which all students might take some questions, while other fourth dimension-consuming portions of the test are given to equivalent samples of students? With matrix sampling, the focus is on schoolhouse and commune scores, non individual test results. (The National Assessment of Educational Progress, or NAEP, uses matrix sampling.)
  • Will the Smarter Balanced assessments effectively mensurate career readiness, all the same it's defined?

Summing up the dilemma facing the state, Kirst said in an interview, "We haven't figured all of this out still. It'southward very circuitous."

To go more than reports similar this ane, click here to sign up for EdSource's no-cost daily electronic mail on latest developments in education.